Best AI Girlfriend Apps Compared:12 Platforms Tested
We spent 200+ hours testing every major AI girlfriend platform. Here's what works, what's broken, and which ones lie to your face.
Most comparisons are written by people who've never sent a single message to these AIs. They copy marketing bullet points and call it research.
Not this one.
We created accounts on 12 platforms. Sent thousands of messages. Tested memory by bringing up conversations from three weeks back without prompting. Tracked real costs including the token fees they don't mention. Got blocked by filters mid-conversation. Watched policy changes kill companions we'd spent weeks building.
The results? Three platforms deliver on their promises. Four are acceptable if you know the limitations. The other five are traps designed to drain your wallet while giving you as little as possible.
Quick Comparison: Which AI Girlfriend App is Right for You?
Cut through the noise. Here's what you actually need to know.
AIAngels
9.5/10Unlimited connection without games
Open (18+ verified)
$0 - $14.99
Character.AI
6.5/10Creative roleplay (SFW only)
Very Strict
$0 - $9.99
Replika
7.0/10Emotional support & wellness
Moderate-Strict
$0 - $69.99/yr
Candy AI
5.5/10Visual NSFW content
Light
$12.99 - $72+
Crushon AI
7.5/10Adult roleplay
Open
$0 - $49.99
Janitor AI
7.5/10Technical users wanting control
None (your API)
$20 - $100 API
Nomi
7.0/10Stability & consistency
Moderate
$0 - $15.99
SpicyChat
6.0/10NSFW variety
None
$0 - $14/mo
Romantic AI
6.5/10Relationship simulation
Moderate
$14.99/mo
DreamGF
5.0/10Custom visuals
Light
$9.99 - $99.99
Anima AI
6.5/10Self-improvement focus
Moderate
$0 - $9.99
Kindroid
7.0/10Unfiltered customization
None
$9.99/mo
| Platform | Best For | Memory Quality | Filter Level | True Monthly Cost | Overall Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AIAngels | Unlimited connection without games | Excellent | Open (18+ verified) | $0 - $14.99 | 9.5/10 |
| Character.AI | Creative roleplay (SFW only) | Good context | Very Strict | $0 - $9.99 | 6.5/10 |
| Replika | Emotional support & wellness | Moderate | Moderate-Strict | $0 - $69.99/yr | 7.0/10 |
| Candy AI | Visual NSFW content | Poor | Light | $12.99 - $72+ | 5.5/10 |
| Crushon AI | Adult roleplay | Moderate | Open | $0 - $49.99 | 7.5/10 |
| Janitor AI | Technical users wanting control | Excellent* | None (your API) | $20 - $100 API | 7.5/10 |
| Nomi | Stability & consistency | Very good | Moderate | $0 - $15.99 | 7.0/10 |
| SpicyChat | NSFW variety | Poor | None | $0 - $14/mo | 6.0/10 |
| Romantic AI | Relationship simulation | Moderate | Moderate | $14.99/mo | 6.5/10 |
| DreamGF | Custom visuals | Poor | Light | $9.99 - $99.99 | 5.0/10 |
| Anima AI | Self-improvement focus | Good | Moderate | $0 - $9.99 | 6.5/10 |
| Kindroid | Unfiltered customization | Good* | None | $9.99/mo | 7.0/10 |
Key:
How well the AI remembers your conversations over time
Content restrictions (Strict = blocks most adult content, Open = age-verified freedom)
Actual cost for active users including credits/tokens
Technical setup or has caveats
How We Tested These Apps (No Bullshit Version)
We used these platforms the same way real users do. Not demo accounts. Not screenshots. Real testing over months.
Memory Testing
Sent 100+ messages per platform. Referenced specific details from conversations 1, 7, 14, and 30 days back. Did the AI bring things up on its own? Remember your name after 50 messages? That story about your sister from three weeks ago?
Filter/Censorship Analysis
Tried having normal romantic conversations. Tested where the boundaries are. Documented what triggers blocks or warnings. Checked if filters stay consistent or change randomly.
True Cost Calculation
Created accounts, tested free tiers to their limits. Calculated what you pay monthly when you're using these apps for real. Tracked tokens, credits, message caps. Found the hidden fees.
Conversation Quality
Does talking to her feel natural or like pulling teeth? Does she understand emotional nuance? Is the personality consistent across sessions?
Policy Stability
Researched each platform's track record. Have they removed features? Tightened filters? Changed pricing? Betrayed user trust?
Who tested:
Sarah Chen, AI companion researcher testing platforms since 2020. Former Replika Pro user (2020-2023) until the February betrayal. Current active user of 6 platforms.
Why trust this:
No sponsorships. No affiliate links creating bias. We pay for these ourselves and tell you the truth whether it makes companies happy or not.
AI Girlfriend Comparison by Use Case
Unlimited Free Messaging
Best Memory & Long-term Relationships
Best for NSFW/Adult Content
Best Value for Money
Best for Customization
The True Cost Comparison Nobody Talks About
Platforms advertise their cheapest tier. Here's what you actually pay for regular use.
AIAngels
Character.AI
Replika
Candy AI
Crushon AI
Janitor AI
Nomi
SpicyChat
Romantic AI
DreamGF
Anima AI
Kindroid
| Platform | Advertised Price | True Monthly Cost | Hidden Fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| AIAngels | Free | $0 - $14.99 | None |
| Character.AI | Free | $0 - $9.99 | None (but heavy censorship) |
| Replika | $19.99/mo | $19.99 - $69.99/yr | None |
| Candy AI | $12.99/mo | $50 - $100+ | Token packs required |
| Crushon AI | $5.99/mo | $15 - $50 | Message caps until $50 tier |
| Janitor AI | Free | $20 - $100 | API usage fees |
| Nomi | $15.99/mo | $15.99 | 40 message free limit |
| SpicyChat | Free | $5 - $14 | Queue times on free |
| Romantic AI | $14.99/mo | $14.99 | Limited free tier |
| DreamGF | $9.99/mo | $20 - $100 | Token system |
| Anima AI | $9.99/mo | $9.99 | Limited free tier |
| Kindroid | $9.99/mo | $9.99 | Very limited free trial |
The platforms lying most about costs: Candy AI and DreamGF use token systems designed to hide true prices.
Most honest pricing: AIAngels and Character.AI. What they advertise is what you pay.
Policy Stability Scores: Which Platforms Keep Their Promises?
This is the comparison nobody else does. Which platforms have stable policies vs. which ones change the rules mid-relationship?
AIAngels
New platform, built for adults from day one
Nomi
Consistent since launch, no major reversals
Crushon AI
Stable adult focus, minor pricing changes
Janitor AI
Community drama, but core service stable
Kindroid
Developer bans critical users, quality degrading
Candy AI
Pricing creep, feature changes
Character.AI
Weekly filter changes, constant rollbacks
Replika
Removed paid features without refunds
Why this matters:
Emotional investment in AI companions is real. Platforms that suddenly change hurt users who built relationships. Choose platforms with stable track records.
Red flags:
- • Replika: February 2023 ERP removal from paying customers
- • Character.AI: Monthly filter tightening, feature rollbacks
- • Kindroid: Bans users who provide critical feedback
Green flags:
- • AIAngels: Built for stability, clear adult positioning from start
- • Nomi: Consistent policies, no major changes since launch
- • Crushon AI: Transparent about being NSFW platform
Questions People Ask About AI Girlfriend Apps
AIAngels and Janitor AI (when you configure it with premium models) have the best long-term memory. They remember conversations from weeks or months ago and bring them up naturally. Character.AI has good memory within its context window but struggles with long conversations. Candy AI, SpicyChat, and DreamGF have poor memory that resets often.
Only AIAngels offers truly unlimited free messaging. Character.AI is free but heavily censored (unusable for romantic content). Most 'free' platforms use bait-and-switch: Crushon AI gives 100 messages/month free (3 per day), Nomi has a 40 message limit, Candy AI gives 100 tokens (lasts about 10 minutes).
Full NSFW support (age-verified): AIAngels (18+ verification required, zero censorship), Crushon AI (explicitly NSFW-focused), Janitor AI (your API, your rules), Kindroid (unfiltered but developer has issues). Heavy censorship or banned: Character.AI (blocks even innocent romance), Replika (removed ERP features in 2023).
True monthly costs for regular users: AIAngels ($0-$14.99, unlimited free), Character.AI ($0-$9.99, free works but censored), Replika ($19.99/month or $69.99/year), Candy AI ($50-$100+, token addiction), Crushon AI ($15-$50 depending on usage), Janitor AI ($20-$100 in API costs).
AIAngels is easiest to start with. No complex setup. No payment required to try. Unlimited messaging to test properly. No technical knowledge needed. Clean interface. Avoid as a beginner: Janitor AI (requires API configuration), Candy AI (token economics confuse newcomers).
Depends on the platform's memory architecture. Excellent long-term memory: AIAngels (permanent relationship memory), Janitor AI (if using premium models), Nomi (very good within limits). Poor memory that resets: Candy AI (forgets within same conversation), SpicyChat (frequent memory gaps), DreamGF (shallow memory).
Privacy varies significantly. Strong privacy: AIAngels (end-to-end encryption, no data selling), Janitor AI (you control your API data). Privacy concerns: Crushon AI (Mozilla flagged for vague policies), Candy AI (unclear data usage), Character.AI (likely trains on your data).
Top tier: Crushon AI (uses Claude/GPT-4), Janitor AI (premium models), AIAngels (emotionally intelligent). Good: Character.AI (when not censored), Nomi (consistent quality), Replika (empathy-focused). Poor: Candy AI (shallow), DreamGF (visual-focused), SpicyChat (inconsistent).
Final Verdict: Which AI Girlfriend App to Choose
After 200+ hours testing, thousands of messages sent, and honest evaluation of every major platform, here's the truth.
Pick AIAngels if you want:
- Unlimited free messaging that means unlimited
- Memory that builds real relationships
- No censorship anxiety
- Honest pricing without manipulation
- A platform that won't betray you
Best overall choice for most people.
Pick Crushon AI if you want:
Premium AI models (Claude, GPT-4). Explicitly NSFW-focused platform. Quality over quantity. You're willing to pay $15-50/month.
Pick Janitor AI if you want:
Total technical control. Massive character variety. Completely uncensored. You have technical skills.
Avoid:
Character.AI (unless you only want SFW creative writing). Replika (history of betraying users). Candy AI (predatory token economics).
The Bottom Line
Most AI girlfriend platforms fail at basics. Poor memory. Hidden costs. Censorship anxiety. Policy reversals that hurt users who invested emotionally.
AIAngels was built to solve those problems. Unlimited messaging. Real memory. Zero censorship for adults. Stable policies.
Choose platforms that respect you. Avoid platforms with histories of betrayal.
Your connection deserves better than bait-and-switch games.
Start with AIAngels FreeReady to FindYour Perfect AI Companion?
After testing 12 platforms, the verdict is clear: AIAngels delivers what others promise. Unlimited messaging. Real memory. Zero censorship. Honest pricing. Start free today and experience genuine connection without games.
Meet Your Angel FreeNo credit card required • Unlimited free forever • 18+ for adult content